When healing is taboo

In a culture that praises perfection, seeking help for mental illness can be an act of rebellion.

Author Image
WRITER
Dec 28, 2021 UPDATED
Featured Article

When I was growing up, my household treated therapy with about the same respect as fortune telling. To my Indian immigrant parents, it was a luxury Americans flippantly wasted money on, in the same vein as indulgent spa treatments and personal fitness trainers.

As a teen, I didn’t know anyone who regularly saw a therapist, which limited my exposure to and understanding of counseling to what I saw in movies: couples bickering in front of a bespectacled woman.

As I grew up and went to college, I knew that this basic mistrust is not shared in all homes. I learned that many of my non-immigrant peers grew up viewing therapy as an occasionally necessary tool for self-improvement. 

So what made my family different?

A culture of pressure

Indian culture prioritizes studying hard and working harder, which can often lead to the reduction of personal problems to “distractions'' which are brushed aside.

But gross neglect of mental illness combined with a lack of access to mental health services has led to damaging effects in India and among non-resident Indians across the globe. A 2017 study found that 197.3 million people live with mental disorders in India, including 45.7 million with depressive disorders and 44.9 million with anxiety disorders. 

Among those Indians not born into wealth (which, in a country with a population of 1.5 billion, is most people), many bear the heavy burden of being the sole hope of ending generations of low-to-middle-class economic standing. 

Hence, the importance placed on studying and working as potential paths to financial success. This unyielding pressure to catapult one’s family into a higher class takes its toll on the psyche. And while emigrating to Western countries can be seen as a sign of success, it doesn’t dissolve the cycle of pressure.

Indian immigrants who grew up feeling the onus to bring their families out of poverty often impose similar expectations on their own children, who then feel the pressure to maintain the upward trajectory their parents achieved and to establish a lasting legacy of success. Success, in this case, is measured by a high salary and a well-timed, suitable marriage.

Failure is measured not only by the absence of these markers, but by any perceived defect—even those out of one’s control. Issues like sexual assault, substance abuse, marital problems, or mental illness are “imperfections,” and contribute to eroding the standing of a family.

This unyielding pressure to catapult one’s family into a higher class takes its toll on the psyche.

Indian culture radiates supreme joy, innovation, and vibrant colors; but in the shadows of this luminescence lurks a tradition of shame and debilitating pride. Acknowledging pain or “failure” is treated as anathema to the resilience of our culture, and so that pain is often ignored altogether. When internalized, this stigma only amplifies pain and shame.

Hidden suffering 

The stigma around conversations about mental health and the ensuing culture of shame has led to devastating effects in India. In 2016, an alarming report claimed that India made up 36% of all suicides reported globally for women that year.

A Monarch by SimplePractice infographic showing the percentage of the world's suicides that occur in India, broken down by gender.

In an interview with NPR, one author of the study, Lakshmi Vijaykumar, a psychiatrist with 25 years of experience in suicide prevention strategies, spoke about the mental health crisis in India.

Vijaykumar references a 2014 World Health Organization study that found Asian women had the highest suicide rates in the world, reporting that 60% of all women who died by suicide in 2014 were from India and China.

Vijaykumar emphasizes how suicide has yet to be decriminalized in Indian law: The Indian Penal Code (IPC 309) still levies punishment for attempted suicide. This contributes to the stigmatization of suicide, consequentially contributing to deaths by suicide.

Breaking the taboo 

Bearing witness to members of my community who have suffered due to both the pressure to be a golden child and the compounding shame around that suffering left me not wanting to be a statistic.

As I set out on my own, I made friends who shared how therapy was and continues to be crucial in helping them understand their relationships and behavior. Others said therapy had helped them dissect and heal from trauma. They showed me that vulnerability and a willingness to examine your demons is an expression of strength.

Acknowledging pain or “failure” is treated as anathema to the resilience of our culture, and so that pain is often ignored altogether.

I had been trained to hide unpleasant emotions, which, of course, meant they just bubbled under the surface. I had spent my life avoiding and burying so many memories and feelings I didn’t want to confront. I wanted the chance to address and unpack them with a therapist.

And if deciding to care for my mental health served as further rebellion against cultural norms, so be it. 

But it wasn’t that easy. The closest I had ever gotten to therapy in my twenties was weekly doses of Super Soul Sunday with Oprah. My enthusiasm for beginning therapy withered when I discovered the personally unachievable cost of therapy. And so, I placed my mental health on the backburner until I could afford the luxury. It would turn into years of waiting. 

A Monarch by SimplePractice illustration of a woman dressed in gray walking a black and white dog on a yellow leash.

At 30, I quit my non-profit job and began the exciting yet financially unstable pursuit of a career in comedy. On Medicaid for the first time in my life, I was astonished to discover that my new health insurance offered therapy at select locations with zero copay. Ironically, it only took having a distressingly low monthly income and needing government assistance to afford therapy! 

I had spent my life avoiding and burying so many memories and feelings I didn’t want to confront.

It couldn’t have come at a better time. As I gained traction in the comedy scene, I began to perform almost every night of the week. With the increasing success came mounting feelings of anxiety leading up to, during, and/or after a performance. I hoped therapy would assist in addressing my anxiety before it was debilitating.

But now, a year into biweekly sessions with my therapist, I've been shocked at the breadth of the discoveries and healing my sessions have provided me. In one meeting, I casually brought up a romantic relationship from a decade ago that I was sure I had moved on from. Minutes later, I found myself crying while recounting specific details.

I discovered I had unconsciously buried that experience out of habit, never addressing its profound impact on my psyche and heart. 

I placed my mental health on the backburner until I could afford the luxury. It would turn into years of waiting. 

I still often start speaking to my therapist about a specific topic totally composed and collected, only to have a stream of tears reveal the depth of something I thought I had already figured out and self-treated. Having a therapist validate my pain and work with me to examine key events impacting my life has provided me with newfound strength.

I’ve never spoken to my parents about being in therapy. Maybe I’m still avoiding the hard conversations around a stigma that is alive and breathing. Saving face by any means necessary is still a stain on an Indian culture that preaches family values.

Until the stigma around mental health is widely dismantled in Indian culture, feelings of shame, hopelessness, and isolation will lead to reluctance in asking for help or seeking treatment, undoubtedly resulting in more suffering.

I feel lucky and grateful to have been initiated into the unofficial club of therapy enthusiasts and hope to see steps towards improved access, awareness, and acceptance regarding mental health in the Indian community. Pursuing treatment for mental health concerns can be the best method to stop the bleeding.

Pain can live on the surface, be buried in our subconscious, or habitually ignored altogether. It is an act of strength, courage, and love to enter the dark caves where our pain lives and is well worth the long voyage towards the light.

Article originally published Apr 21, 2021. Updated Dec 28, 2021.
  • Dandona, R., Kumar, G. A., Dhaliwal, R. S., Naghavi, M., Vos, T., Shukla, D. K., … Khanna, T. (2018). Gender differentials and state variations in suicide deaths in India: the Global Burden of Disease Study 1990–2016. The Lancet Public Health, 3(10), e478–e489. https://doi.org/10.1016/s2468-2667(18)30138-5

  • Sagar, R., Dandona, R., Gururaj, G., Dhaliwal, R. S., Singh, A., Ferrari, A., et al. (2020). The burden of mental disorders across the states of India: the Global Burden of Disease Study 1990–2017. The Lancet Psychiatry, 7(2), 148–161. https://doi.org/10.1016/s2215-0366(19)30475-4

Find a therapist

Find a therapist and request an appointment today via our secure online portal.

Monarch does not employ any provider and is not responsible for the conduct of any provider listed on our site. All information in member profiles, and messages are created from data provided by the providers and not generated or verified by Monarch. As a user, you need to perform your own diligence to ensure the provider you choose is appropriate for your needs and complies with applicable laws and licensure requirements. Monarch is not intended to be a substitute for professional advice.

Monarch assumes no responsibility, and shall not be liable, for the quality or any other aspect of the services a provider may provide to you, nor will Monarch be liable for any act, omission or wrongdoing committed or allegedly committed by any provider.

Articles and information and assessments posted on Monarch are for informational purposes only, and it is not intended to diagnose or treat any health conditions. Treatment and diagnosis should be performed by an appropriate health care provider.

IN THE EVENT OF AN EMERGENCY, DO NOT USE MONARCH. IF YOU ARE EXPERIENCING A MEDICAL EMERGENCY, OR THINKING ABOUT SUICIDE OR HARMING YOURSELF OR OTHERS, CALL 911 IMMEDIATELY OR ANOTHER APPLICABLE EMERGENCY NUMBER.